Requesting changes. I re-reviewed the current PR head (5cc3b5e) against implementation/testing references. Remaining gaps still block approval.
Re-reviewed PR #8 on head 8e64ef22e22bcee2856ab42c1536c6b4c3ef05fa with the same review lanes. The branch is much closer, but I still found blocking issues plus a few remaining completeness gaps.
Still requesting changes after re-review on ac16b1909cdcb9627903b50dc7542e9d6160e416.
Still requesting changes after re-review on bbc3813ff8407068b3c2018c0c40f7ac3b4e3db3.
Addendum from the infra lane after the main review was posted:
- Medium:
docker-compose.ymlstill givesarchive-workera no-op healthcheck (python -c "print('ok')"), so compose can report…
Still requesting changes after re-review on 89f3fccc718860498fd386dafa8331e73fc37a21.
Requesting changes again. This head is substantially better and it fixed the previous backup-format mismatch. I re-validated the builds and backend/tests/unit/test_phase4.py now passes with 86 passed. There are still a few remaining issues before I can approve.
Requesting changes again. This head is materially better, and I re-checked it assuming the real Keycloak/OpenBao/Storage Box setup is now in place. The backend/postgres images build and backend/tests/unit/test_phase4.py now passes (71 passed), but there are still remaining correctness/completeness issues.
Requesting changes again. I re-reviewed the current head (456556460979ca391afa13cdca218f4219a0e8fa) and there are still blocking Phase 4 gaps.
Requesting changes. I re-reviewed the current PR head and the branch is still below approval for Phase 4.